Karmelo Anthony case

What Happened

• On April 2, during a high school track meet in Frisco, Texas, 17-year-old Karmelo Anthony allegedly got into a confrontation with another student, Austin Metcalf.

• Police allege an argument over seating escalated when Anthony pulled a knife and stabbed Metcalf in the chest, resulting in his death.

Charges & Indictment

• A Collin County grand jury has now indicted Anthony on first-degree murder charges.

• If convicted, he could face 5 to 99 years, or life in prison, and a possible fine up to $10,000.

Bail, Release & Conditions

• Initially held on $1 million bond, prosecutors later agreed on a reduction to $250,000 during a bond hearing on April 14.

• Conditions of release:

  • House arrest with ankle monitor

  • Remain at family home (even moved to a safer location)

  • No contact with the Metcalf family

  • Supervised outings and weekly check-ins with court officials 

Defense & Prosecution Perspectives

• Anthony's defense: emphasizes his lack of criminal history, strong community ties, good academic record and sports leadership; they contend the act was self-defense .

• Prosecution: argues that bond should ensure community safety and ensure Anthony appears in court; labeled the killing as “brutal murder”.

Evidence Presented

• Statements from witnesses who said Anthony invited confrontation and then pulled out a knife.

• Anthony allegedly told officers: “I did it”, but later also indicated he feared for his life.

Current Status

• Anthony is living with his family under house arrest in Frisco, wearing an ankle monitor.

• No trial date has been scheduled yet; court timing will be set by local court officials.

Community Reactions & Impact

• Online petitions (17,000+ signatures) are urging the school to award a posthumous diploma to Austin Metcalf, who passed away before graduation.

• Both families have faced harassment, including “swatting” calls and threats; law enforcement is investigating.

• Public debate continues over bail-reform, racial bias in charging minors as adults, and the spread of misinformation in high-profile cases.

Quick Summary Table

Topic	Details
Victim	Austin Metcalf, killed April 2
Suspect	Karmelo Anthony, 17/18
Charge	First-degree murder
Bond	Lowered from $1M to $250K
Release Conditions	House arrest, ankle monitor, no contact
Trial	No date set yet

Bottom Line

The case has transitioned from a local tragedy to a serious legal and societal issue, involving adult charges for a teen, high bail vs. community concerns, and racial, legal, and emotional complexities. The next critical phase is the court procedure leading up to trial.

Would you like:

• A breakdown of Texas juvenile-to-adult charging laws?

• Comparative insights into bail reform debates?

• Historical cases of minors charged as adults in Texas?